ValiantFans.com Board - Since 2004

Potentially, the most interesting thing in a hypothetical meeting between VH-1 Faith and VEI Faith would be the latter's relationship with VEI Archer, where, in contrast, VH-1 Archer married VH-1 Flamingo.


I have zero interest in the old Valiant being brought into modern day. Bring back the ...

One interesting aspect of a meeting between the three Faiths (VH-1, VH-2, and VH-3) would be that the first one would be the eldest of the group, having been born in the '70s (the second one would be only slightly younger, having been born in 1981), and also have had more experience as a member of ...

At the end of Resurgence, the VEI iterations of the VALIANT characters became lost in the multiverse.

Most are in the Underdeadside, some are still in the VEI reality, and Aram and Faith appear to be lost in the bridge between them.

What if Faith and Aram end up finding their way to the VH-1 and ...

Your definition of terrible is "if it's not like it was in the '90s, it's bad no matter who does it".

Nothing I saw from the Antos and Hawkins eras contradicted the world Dinesh built. He might have taken things in a different direction, but that doesn't mean that what they did wasn't ...

The comics are terrible. That's not really up for debate.

If you can't see bad editing, you aren't qualified to talk about editing.


Your definition of terrible is "if it's not like it was in the '90s, it's bad no matter who does it".

Nothing I saw from the Antos and Hawkins eras ...

Here's something I found in literally one second of looking:

"Garbled mess of a story
Made even worse with Fred Van Lente’s ‘funny’ quips
Forced cameos by virtually every character in the Valiant U for ‘reasons’ :?

But when you think we’ve hit rock bottom…enter Psi Lords facepalm

1/5 amateur hour ...

You can move on from this focus on disproving the theory at any time. You are separate person; your posts don’t have to always be in reaction to a single theme. You can even juggle two posts in different threads addressing two disparate topics at the same time. Why not call out bad ...

Ricomortis wrote: Fri Feb 03, 2017 11:28 pm

Oh man.... Now THAT is exactly how I picture Shadowman. I wish VEI would take him in this direction. Mysterious, mystical and 100% Adult oriented.

Would be a big hit IMO.

Rico

Why would it not just be exactly as big a failure as when Acclaim did it that way?

double post

You can move on from this focus on disproving the theory at any time. You are separate person; your posts don’t have to always be in reaction to a single theme. You can even juggle two posts in different threads addressing two disparate topics at the same time. Why not call out bad editing ...

You can move on from this focus on disproving the theory at any time. You are separate person; your posts don’t have to always be in reaction to a single theme. You can even juggle two posts in different threads addressing two disparate topics at the same time. Why not call out bad editing now ...

RyanMcLelland wrote: Tue Apr 15, 2025 4:37 am
It sounds like Alien and DMG work together on the books (Alien has to run everything past DMG) so I imagine IDW is helping from a publisher standpoint.

Because they are the same company

Then what's the problem?

Dinesh set up his own world building for VEI, and DMG and Alien have been consistent with it.


You didn't answer the question though, it had nothing to do with VEI vs DMG. I'll make it more clear for you:

Here's what I don't understand. You've railed for decades that ...

He sounds clueless.

double post

Was there a mistake in the first place? We assume that there was a way to accomplish everything he accomplished and not get pushed out but I don't think that's true. Lets look at what was accomplished

He brought Valiant back
He maintained the core feel and ideas
It was a sales success
It was a ...

Avoiding MOTA?

not sure you realize this, or maybe you fought for the other team, but without question and according to all facts (not opinions) , Crusaders were the good guys


Crusaders from the middle ages? Definitely not the good guys lol. Unless bloodshed, unprovoked violence and religious persecution are ...

Something we can all agree on. Happy Birthday Dinesh Shamdasani

I say if you’re in contact with Lapham - show the proof. As already stated - the email has already been revealed. Don’t have the balls to show an actual email? Copy and paste. I’d love to dissect it to see if it’s real or just something you whip up yourself to try and fool everyone.

I think it’s ...

Just saw bad idea announced its first gold logo book for planet death. theyre giving them away at emerald city comic con this weekend. its funny how hard dinesh tries to go from valiant but can't help himself. cool looking cover. the gold always works.

Sure. But when Shooter did it alone at Dark Horse, the writing was just not as good even if the art looked the same. Something -- or someone -- was missing.


Yeah Layton, BWS, Perlin, Jayjay, Nichols, Lapham etc. etc. were all super important to Valiant's early success. I never said it was all ...

Perhaps it's just me who thinks this, but I think they should bring Dinesh back into the company. Under him, Valiant was doing great. Ideally, whoever is in charge needs to let Valiant rest for a while, get Dinesh back in, and regroup. Just my silly little opinion tho :)


If DMG licensed the ...

Perhaps it's just me who thinks this, but I think they should bring Dinesh back into the company. Under him, Valiant was doing great. Ideally, whoever is in charge needs to let Valiant rest for a while, get Dinesh back in, and regroup. Just my silly little opinion tho :)


This would be amazing ...

If there were clear answers as to the rights, that would likely mitigate the hostility.

I doubt it, the trolls would just find (or create) something else to complain about.

Again, if people aren't satisfied with the answers midnightonearth gave about the rights, they have every right to ...